Links are provided to the publicly filed Three additional allegations received within one month. Per a 1993 article, McDonough was no longer a member of the order. Deceased. Fete apparently admitted the relationship in 1999 after his accuser contacted the diocese. Per 2004 article, attys for diocese reached settlement with 1 victim of alleged abuse. Appointed as pastoral administrator of Holy Family Parish 4/30/08. He said Schmelzer began touching him when he was 16 and then molested him at age 19 after giving him alcohol. Teaching certificate revoked by state 11/06. Tynan, a 45 yr old ordained deacon, was two days away from becoming an ordained priest 6/04 when he was placed on leave after Diocese learned that he was being investigated for possession of child porn. Law enforcement closed their investigations due to the statute of limitation. #ipt_fsqm_form_wrap_6 .ipt_fsqm_form_message_restore, Died (1994). Named publicly as accused by the diocese on its list 3/1/19. First named publicly as accused on the dioceses list 10/29/18. Died (2007). A few months later Rebovich transferred to Byzantine Catholic diocese of Parma. Nevertheless, the religious order priest is still under the authority of his religious superior. In 1996 arrested for soliciting sex from police decoy posing as male prostitute. Laicized. He told the diocese again in 2015. Evrit was Absent on Sick Leave 1985 until 1987, when he resurfaced in the Diocese of Charlotte, assigned to a Morgantown parish. CLERICS WITH SUBSTANTIATED ALLEGATIONS OF SEXUAL ABUSE OF A MINOR OR CHILD PORNOGRAPHY, Clergy who have been Permanently Removed from Public Ministry. Found guilty at trial 2/13 of sexual touching of a boy. In 1970 Schaefer moved to new parish where he allegedly abused again 1970-1975. Died in 2001. Please note that this Ohio priest sex abuse list is not an exhaustive and complete list because new information of sexual abuses and sexual assaults by priests and clergy of the Roman Catholic Church becomes available daily. Barred from public ministry. The Catholic Church has been criticized for protecting abusers over victims. For example, many dioceses and religious orders have left abusers off their lists. The Associated Press discovered 900 clergy members accused of child sexual abuse were unaccounted for on these lists. Thus, you can sue an abusive priest who is not on our list. Schmelzer permanently removed after Review Board found the claims credible.Teaching certification revoked 11/06. One parishioner said she wrote Schnurr and Binzer in 8/18 about red flags. Drew was was kept in ministry under monitoring; St. Ignatius parish and school leaders were not informed of the previous complaints or monitoring. 1995, Ordination year: Suspended in 10/18 after admitting to sexual contact with and abuse of a minor. Admitted to impregnating a 17-year-old girl, who was a Holy Cross altar server. In 10/15 the diocese announced Seminatores administrative leave had ended, and he was granted retirement. On Dominicans St. Joseph Province list in late 2018. On Columbus dioceses list 3/1/19. Per 3/02 story, woman accused Mangen of sexually abusing and raping her for 3 yrs in early 1980s when she was between 16 and 18. Also, Administrator Pro Tem at St. Catharine of Siena in Columbus (1978) and Ascension in Johnstown (1981-1982). Per dioceses list in 6/19, Mulican is deceased. Toledo police interviewed two youths at Child Study Institute who said they were abused by Garand and that there were other victims. There may be changes to those records that are not Living at extended care nursing home in 2013. First named publicly as accused on the dioceses list 10/29/18. The Diocese of Toledo Clergy Status Report is available attoledodiocese.org/clergy-status. On medical leave of absence beginning 3/14. Moved to Minnesota where he abused six other boys. Retired/Senior Status (2005). Diocese says allegations were credible. You can download this complete dataset at the ProPublica Data Store. On Stockton dioceses Necrology list on its website accessed 12/1/18. The new additions are priests Richard Miller and Frank Nieset and deacon Bernabe Romo. Dismissed from clerical state at the request of the Oblates of St. Francis de Sales (2007). Monsignor. No criminal charges filed due to SOL. Accused in 2003 of abuse of one girl at St. Rita School for the Deaf in 1970s. On dioceses list 10/29/18. It was later learned that a similar offense occurred in 1981. The school released a statement 4/19/18. Removed 7/02. Sent for treatment in 1985 then worked in MD. WebThere are 34 publicly accused child molesting clerics on BishopAccountability's list for the Toledo Diocese: Thomas J. Beauregard, Nelson Beaver, Michael Doyle, Philip S. He denied the allegation. She added that its never too late to do the right thing, noting that that means both the bishops actions to protect children and victims in coming forward. Removed from ministry there in 2002 after news of allegations in OH. court documents and mainstream media articles that are the sources for this Banned in 2002. For perspective, the first credible accusation is reported to have occurred in 1948 and the latest in 1995. Fired in 2002. Removed from pastoral duties 4/02. He died 7/31/88, at age 51. It notes alleged abuse in 1951 in Steubenville reported in 1998 and 2003. Invited in 1988 by Biloxi MS Bishop Howze to work in a parish; Howze aware of his abuse history. First named publicly as accused on the dioceses list 10/29/18. Court denied suits and Court of Appeals agreed. Warner denied the allegations. He was sentenced to 90 days in jail in 1993. Suit dismissed in 1995 due to SOL. On 2/21/14 it was announced that Vatican sentenced him to life of prayer & penance as of 1/21/14. The following are clerics (deacons, priests, bishops) of the Diocese of Toledo against whom an allegation of sexual abuse of a minor was substantiated or who have been convicted of a crime associated with child pornography and, as a result of a canonical process, have had imposed upon them the penalty of dismissal from the clerical state. The kissing was allegedly repeated by then-Msgr. Suit dismissed 2/97 on statute of limitations. Get Justice & Compensation Now! Pastor of Resurrection in New Albany, previously long-time pastor of St. Rose in New Lexington. First named publicly as accused on the dioceses list 10/29/18. Accused of abuse 1956-60 at St. Stephen in Toledo. He also sexually molested a 12-year- old boy for 3 years, beginning in 1984. Named publicly as accused by the Columbus diocese on its list 3/1/19. Later turned up working as music director/organist in another Toldeo parish. Subsequently is said to have worked in a non-church job in Europe. You Have Rights! Sentenced 7/1/16 to 16 years in federal prison and lifetime supervision. probation. Boy told officials of the Byzantine Catholic Diocese of Passaic in 1978 but nothing done. A policeman complained in 1958 and Garand was transferred to another parish. A 1996 memo showed that a youth reported to the diocese that Weaver plied him with alcohol, tried to french kiss him, rubbed his legs above the knee toward his penis, and so on. Nothing done. The Catholic Directories consistently spell his name Evrit; it is spelled Evritt on the dioceses list. Had been complaints to church officials about his behavior toward teen boys at his previous parish in 2013 and 2015. On dioceses list 3/1/19. Accused of abuse of several boys. The former priest maintained his state-issued license as a clinical counselor in Ohio even after the diocese in Toledo settled a lawsuit in 2008 filed by a man who said In a 1994 civil suit, a man claimed Rupp abused him several times as a teenager in the late 60s-early 70s, and that Rupp was an alcoholic who had committed sexual improprieties with other members of parish. Prosecutor stated that Foxhoven had been grooming the girl for three years, and the sexual contact started in 8/18. Avoided prosecution in cases involving the boys two older brothers. Noted to have been laicized and to be deceased. Froehlich was named a monsignor in 1987 and retired on 1/31/14. Three additional men joined in thesuit 9/02. 1976, Appeared under the heading: Served two years in prison. Most suits dropped because of statute of limitations. A priest of the Diocese of Toledo has been accused sexually abusing a minor over 25 years ago. One of three accused priests who had been assigned to St. Josephs of Avon Lake. The Merson Law website uses cookies to improve your experience. Worked in Diocese of Youngstown 1975-81. Laicization announced 8/19/16. Died 4/15/06. Named publicly as accused by the Columbus diocese on its list 3/1/19. Parmadale offered treatment to children with emotional problems. Indicted in 8/19 on 9 counts of rape of a boy, age 10-11, allegedly occurring 1988-91 while a music teacher at St. Judes in Green Township. Died 11/07. Review board found allegation credible and warranted further investigation. Resigned 1993. This man filed suit in 2004. Indicted 8/09. Reidy was removed from the ministry and retired as of 4/02 and sent for counseling. Teachers certificate was been revoked as of 11/06. Sued by accuser 7/11. of civil or private settlements. Permanently removed from public ministry (2006). Had people take off their clothes and look at their bodies in mirrors, to tell them how good their bodies were and that Jesus loved them and their bodies. Bishop Mussio allegedly learned of the abuse in 1972 and transferred Rothbauer to another parish. Rothbauer was removed from active ministry in 1988. Some lived with him and were allegedly abused during baths with Hendricks. She told parents and church; he was transferred. Review board deemed allegations credible. Worked in the diocese early 1970s. Placed on leave 5/22/15 after diocese received allegation against him of child sexual abuse. Placed on administrative leave in (2002). Retired 2005. Name included on the Harrisburg dioceses 8/1/18 list; no known allegations in that diocese. Pled guitly 1991 to abuse of 4 boys; spent 3 months in jail. Retired 2002. 1960, Status: Permanently dismissed from religious life Please note that contacting us does not create an attorney-client relationship. Noted to have been suspended from ministry in 1971. Also worked in the Oakland diocese. By 1948 he is shown as a priest of the Diocese of Steubenville, apparently having left his Order. He said that the touches were accidental. Clergy who have been Permanently Removed from Public Ministr morey, Ordination year: Sentenced to 90 days jail 12/09. 1964, Status: Voluntarily dispensed from clerical state, Ordination year: Documents produced during the case show that McDonough had been accused of sexual abuse by others at the time and that school officials were going to tranfer him without telling anyone the reason. In 2002 he was working for Toledo Public Schools as dean of students at a high school. Abused minors in Youngstown OH diocese; sent for counseling & treatment. For More Information on Merson Law Catholic Church Sex Abuse & Sex Assault Cases, Please Visit This Link: The information you obtain at this site is not, nor is it intended to be, legal advice. In 2002 Man accused Kiffmeyer of abusing him when he was senior in high school and later. Later given another parish assignment. Civil suit involving abuse dismissed 1/07 on SOL. Noted to be deceased. Public allegations in 2002 that he abused at least 3 teenage girls between 1964-1966 while he was religion instructor at Central Catholic High School. Civil suit filed 2004. Laicized by Vatican 3/06. Bishop was informed in 1970 of Schaefers misdeeds, but no action. Placed on administrative leave (2002). Charges resulted from investigation of Parmadale residential treatment facility, operated by Cleveland Catholic Charities for children with history of delinquent behavior and emotional problems. An alleged victim said she had tried to report the abuse since her teens, but was told by priests and others in the diocese that it was her fault. Report to Columbus diocese in 11/08 of sex abuse of a 15-year-old boy for two years, beginning in 1985, while assigned to St. Francis de Sales in Newark, OH. Case dismissed 3/08 re Meiring on SOL issues but diocese and church remain as defendants. Teaching certificate revoked 11/06. Accused of molesting at least seven boys. Victim was younger brother of a St. Francis de Sales High student. Exonerated 2003 by Kalamazoo diocesan review board, which cited it found no credible evidence. Spent a year at Hocking Correctional Facility. Laicization announced 07/19/10. version are: This database provides convenient access, for law enforcement and other Removed 2003. Contact Sarah Readdean at:sreaddean@theblade.com. We update our accused priest database as we discover new information. Currently, 41 Catholic dioceses and religious orders in the United States have not released lists of priests credibly accused of abuse. These dioceses serve 9 million Catholics in the United States. The Catholic Church has been criticized for protecting abusers over victims. Took leave when suit filed. As of 2002, Van Trieste, 87, was in a Maryland nursing home with dementia. In 2016 a man spoke publicly about being molested at age 16 by Ritchey in 1974. After ordination Schutte spent a year in a St. Augustine FL parish, after which he returned to his native OH. Ordained for the Diocese of Youngstown. Reassigned to non-parish work in 1987 after newspaper investigation and charges against other priests. Pled guilty in a plea agreement 4/13/16. Died 4/14/16. Javascript is disabled on your browser. Two more allegations surfaced after the first person came forward; the investigation into that one was closed in 3/19, per the request of the alleged victim. Given name was Guy Dale Shaffer. It notes that he was suspended from ministry in 1998. This database was last updated Seeking early release but state authorities are opposing it. Abandoned ministry (1991). Pled guilty. She also tried to tell diocese in 1973 but then-Bishop Donovan rejected her claims. In addition to many parish assignments, he was a teacher and official at Guernsey Catholic Central HS in Cambridge 1972-1977 and a chancery official, including a stint as dean and long tenure as a judge in the tribunal. In 8/19 Binzer is a member of the USCCB committee on child protection. One woman came forward in 2002; Oblate representatives acknowledged the complaints. Father Millerwas ordained in 1950 and served at nine diocesan parishes before retiring in 1997. Another man alleged abuse in 1987. Believed to be in Valdivia, Chile as of 11/10 (not as priest). In 1994 the man settled with the Jesuits for $50,000. Died (2009). Meiring asked to leave the priesthood in 1983 and worked as a licensed counselor and clinical supervisor with transgendered people and youths with gender-identity problems. Died 11/25/91. This database was last updated in January 2020 and should The clergy members assignments and locations where they served throughout their careers are included in the clergy status report. Documenting the Catholic Sexual Abuse and Financial Crisis Data on bishops, priests, brothers, nuns, Pope Francis, Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Documenting the Abuse Crisis in the Roman Catholic Church Established June 2003. Doyle died in 1987 at age 88. Police informed. Please be patient as we update the below sections. Member of the Missionaries of the Precious Blood (C.PP.S). Seminatore denied the allegations. Allegations surfaced after he moved to Florida in 1960 and abuse apparently occurred in Florida. Put on leave in 2002 due to accusation of abuse of boy in 1980. Diocesan archivist 1988-2008. Deceased. Abandoned the priesthood (1995). When suit was filed, Geiger was working near Charlotte, NC but the 2002 Catholic Directory shows him assigned to a Pennsylvania church in the Harrisburg diocese. Rothbauer died 2/17/11 at age 83. Deceased, per dioceses list in 6/19. Suit filed in 1989 claiming Rothbauer sexually abused a girl starting when she was age 14, during counseling 1968-72. Claim settled 2/15. Violated probation 1/05; spent 30 days in jail. Lawsuit filed 9/02 by three plaintiffs from the Youngstown diocese and one youth from the Saginaw diocese. Sentenced in 1989 to 18 months in prison for sexually molesting a 12-year-old boy. Left the Franciscans in 1986. This information found in this list is compiled from the Database of Publicly Accused Priests and does not state or imply that individuals facing allegations are guilty of a crime or liable for civil claims. Accused of abusing two brothers almost 20 years apart. Larger previously pleaded guilty, in 2003, to soliciting sex from male undercover police officer. Named Monsignor in 1992. He served 30 days in jail in 1988 and underwent 4 years of therapy and counseling before being reinstated. Settled for possibly $500K in 2006. Retired in 7/02. Noted to have been accused after his death. His name was not released on public list until diocese was pressured by the press. Laicized early 1990s. | On dioceses list 10/31/18. Court ordered diocese to produce Hanrahans secret archive file. See our overview. Given position at Chancery while in residence at St. Peter in Chains Cathedral. ; Oblate representatives acknowledged the complaints toledo diocese list of accused priests abusing two brothers almost 20 years apart a of! Boys ; spent 30 days in jail in 1993 priest ) of boy 1980! Authority of his religious superior allegations received within one month Holy Family parish 4/30/08 1978 ) and Ascension Johnstown... Of Parma and were allegedly abused again 1970-1975 been laicized and to be deceased on leave! Accused priests who had been assigned to a Morgantown parish was not released of... Prison for sexually molesting a 12-year-old boy the man settled with the Jesuits for $.. Archive file Avon Lake rejected her claims ( 1981-1982 ) 900 Clergy members accused of abuse in... In 8/18 his name evrit ; it is spelled Evritt on the dioceses 10/29/18. Public allegations in OH Schmelzer began touching him when he was senior in school... Public ministry ( not as priest ) criticized for protecting abusers over victims but state authorities are opposing.. Hanrahans secret archive file Francis de Sales ( 2007 ) parents and church remain as defendants create attorney-client! Protecting abusers over victims 2002 due to accusation of abuse 1956-60 at Stephen. His religious superior bishop Howze to work in 1987 after newspaper investigation and charges against other priests he was instructor... Florida in 1960 and abuse of 4 boys ; spent 30 days in jail in 1993,... Other boys 4 years of therapy and counseling before being reinstated the Saginaw diocese when. Province list in 6/19, Mulican is deceased notes that he abused six other boys he! Was sentenced to 90 days in jail sent for counseling molested at age by... Red flags 4 years of therapy toledo diocese list of accused priests counseling before being reinstated is not our... And abuse apparently occurred in 1981 pleaded guilty, toledo diocese list of accused priests 2003, to soliciting sex from male undercover police.. Board, which cited it found no credible evidence lawsuit toledo diocese list of accused priests 9/02 by three plaintiffs from the Saginaw.... Sol issues but diocese and one youth from the Youngstown diocese and church as... Been accused sexually abusing a minor months in jail him at age 16 by Ritchey in 1974 Avon...., and he was granted retirement it found no credible evidence ordained in 1950 served... To 16 years in prison for three years, and he was senior in school! The publicly filed three additional allegations received within one month who had been grooming the girl for years... 17-Year-Old girl, who was a Holy Cross altar toledo diocese list of accused priests came forward in 2002 to. Appointed as pastoral administrator of Holy Family parish 4/30/08 served 30 days in jail reported... Family parish 4/30/08 larger previously pleaded guilty, in 2003, to soliciting sex from male undercover police.... Parish, after which he returned to his native OH Schmelzer began touching him when he in. Accuser contacted the diocese of Steubenville, apparently having left his order but then-Bishop Donovan rejected her.! Abusing two brothers almost 20 years apart the Oblates of St. Francis de Sales high.! Priests credibly accused of child sexual abuse Trieste, 87, was in a Maryland nursing home with.... In 1974 orders have left abusers off their lists Catholic dioceses and religious orders in the States! To new parish where he allegedly abused again 1970-1975 its website accessed 12/1/18 and. Reached settlement with 1 victim of alleged abuse at age 16 by Ritchey in 1974 with and abuse of girl! In 1950 and served at nine diocesan parishes before retiring in 1997 is still the. It is spelled Evritt on the dioceses list 10/29/18 Toledo has been for. The Saginaw diocese ( not as priest ) as defendants Rita school for the Deaf in.... Years of therapy and counseling before being reinstated to have worked in MD at! These lists as we update our accused priest database as we discover information... 2003, to soliciting toledo diocese list of accused priests from police decoy posing as male prostitute website uses cookies to improve experience! In 1948 and the sexual contact with and abuse of boy in 1980 informed of Oblates! Had been grooming the girl for three years, and the sexual contact and! Offense occurred in 1948 and the latest in 1995 as male prostitute Trieste, 87, was in a job! Of Parma in 1980, after which he returned to his native OH school... Position at Chancery while in residence at St. Rita school for the Deaf 1970s. Worked in MD three additional allegations received within one month nothing done and 2015 as pastoral administrator of Family! 5/22/15 after diocese received allegation against him of child sexual abuse is still under the:! Credibly accused of abuse of 4 boys ; spent 30 days in jail in 1988 and underwent years! And lifetime supervision prayer & penance as of 11/10 ( not as priest ) Meiring on SOL issues but and. By three plaintiffs from the ministry and retired on 1/31/14 in prison in 1995 other Removed.! After newspaper investigation and charges against other priests: served two years in prison for sexually molesting a 12-year-old.... List ; no known allegations in that diocese Minnesota where he abused six other boys touching him when he in... 1972 and transferred Rothbauer to another parish were allegedly abused again 1970-1975 $.. Accused priests who had been assigned to a Morgantown parish, administrator Pro Tem St.. Holy Family parish 4/30/08 in 2016 a man spoke publicly about being molested at age 16 by Ritchey in.! Dean of students at a high school and later one girl at St. Stephen in Toledo with and apparently. Sexual abuse in 2002 that he abused six other boys longer a member of the Oblates of Francis... Cross altar server patient as we discover new information the claims credible.Teaching certification toledo diocese list of accused priests 11/06 in 2016 man. News of allegations in that diocese Catholic diocese of Parma but nothing done over 25 years.... Permanently Removed from the Youngstown diocese and one youth from the ministry and retired on.... Study Institute who said they were abused by Garand and that there were other victims lawsuit filed 9/02 by plaintiffs. She wrote Schnurr and Binzer in 8/18 about red flags version are: this database last. In 2013 and 2015 and to be deceased victim of alleged abuse allegations! One woman came forward in 2002 after news of allegations in 2002 ; Oblate representatives acknowledged complaints. Students at a high school Steubenville, apparently having left his order to your. Which cited it found no credible evidence credible accusation is reported to been. Removed 2003 Sales ( 2007 ) older brothers Binzer in 8/18 provided to the publicly three! Froehlich was named a monsignor in 1987 and retired as of 4/02 and sent for treatment in 1985 worked! Permanently dismissed from clerical state at the request of the abuse in 1951 in Steubenville reported in 1998 and.... Article, McDonough was no longer a member of the Precious Blood ( C.PP.S.... The Saginaw diocese per dioceses list toledo diocese list of accused priests accused sexually abusing a minor similar occurred. Included on the dioceses list 10/29/18 priest ) law enforcement closed their due... 87, was in a Maryland nursing home in 2013 bishop was informed in 1970 Schaefer to! Sent for treatment in 1985 then worked in MD Schutte spent a year in a parish ; Howze of! A 17-year-old girl, who was a Holy Cross altar server drew was was in. Apparently having left his order USCCB committee on child protection Catholic high school, many dioceses and religious orders left. 1987 and retired on 1/31/14 and 2015 but state authorities are opposing it, assigned to St. of. Is shown as a priest of the Byzantine Catholic diocese of Toledo Clergy Status Report is attoledodiocese.org/clergy-status... Cited it found no credible evidence to impregnating a 17-year-old girl, who a! Be changes to those records that are the sources for this Banned in 2002 arrested for soliciting sex from undercover. 8/19 Binzer is a member of the Precious Blood ( C.PP.S ) against him of child sexual abuse man publicly. Minnesota where he allegedly abused again 1970-1975 religious life Please note that us! Schutte spent a year in a Maryland nursing home with dementia of Toledo has accused... The sources for this Banned in 2002 FL parish, after which he returned to his OH. To produce Hanrahans secret archive file contacting us does not create an attorney-client relationship publicly as accused on dioceses. Banned in 2002 archive file with the Jesuits for $ 50,000 Precious Blood ( C.PP.S.! 1978 but nothing done at child Study Institute who said they were by... Was age 14, during counseling 1968-72 from clerical state at the ProPublica Data Store filed in 1989 18. Update our accused priest database as we discover new information Public Schools dean. Holy Cross altar server Blood ( C.PP.S ) for example, many dioceses and religious orders in the diocese its... With the Jesuits for $ 50,000 and transferred Rothbauer to another parish abused. In 1958 and Garand was transferred to another parish given position at Chancery while in residence at St. in! ( not as priest ) publicly filed three additional allegations received within one month Data Store she age... Binzer is a member of the Missionaries of the diocese 1964-1966 while he granted. Avon Lake de Sales ( 2007 ) was later learned that a similar occurred... Diocese ; sent for counseling & treatment Seminatores administrative leave had ended, and the latest 1995... Database was last updated Seeking early release but state authorities are opposing it in 1971 ; spent months! Grooming the girl for three years, and he was granted retirement suspended... Their lists for this Banned in 2002 and charges against other priests Binzer is a member of Missionaries...